Forum:Featured Review change

Forums - Featured Review change

This page is waiting to be archived by an administrator. Please do not edit the contents of this page. So, on the featured review nominations page, it says a nomination must have 5+ support at the end of the week, and the problem is - not 5+ people are actually going to vote. We have very little views and acknowledgement that there is a review section - and that's just one thing. The next thing is that featured review nominations get as little views too. Having a requirement of +5 really doesn't fit, to me. Why not do a percentage like we do in rights requests, or similar? If we don't change it somehow - there'll probably be no fresh reviews that will get a nomination. Leave your thoughts and such. --TheNightingale 22:15, 29 May 2014 (UTC) Percentages wouldn't work since there is no oppose section. :P I say change it to a gallery of reviews, sort of like the strip on the Customs main page. That way there is less pressure to get a good review each month; interesting ones should just be nominated as they appear, and no user should have more than two on the main page at a time. Just my thoughts, because the current monthly system hardly worked for reviews at Brickia. And as for acknowledging reviews, where was that forum with the reception section conception? Was a verdict reached there? It probably would not help much, since we don't have that many viewers, but it would help integrate reviews into the site better for when we hopefully do. Berrybrick (talk) 22:57, 29 May 2014 (UTC)